ARK Investment Management asked the SEC on November 20 to withdraw two unlaunched CoinDesk 20 crypto ETF registrations filed in January. One fund tracked the index through futures; the other planned to exclude Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash by shorting CME Bitcoin futures. Neither registration became effective, and neither fund sold shares.
Both products were based on the CoinDesk 20, which tracks the 20 largest crypto assets by market value while excluding stablecoins and memecoins. The index caps its largest constituent at 30% and each other constituent at 20%, with limits applied at quarterly rebalancing; Bitcoin was near the top cap.
Neither ETF would have held crypto directly. Both were registered as commodity pools intended to list on NYSE Arca. The standard fund planned to hold long positions in CoinDesk 20 futures traded on ICE Futures U.S., with cash and Treasury securities for margin. The ex-Bitcoin version was designed to remove both bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash: it would hold the broader index through ICE futures and sell CME Bitcoin futures to offset the Bitcoin exposure. Its draft registration left the ticker, sponsor fee and futures allocation blank.
The article’s hypothetical sizing example assumes a 30% Bitcoin weight and full investment. It describes roughly $43 of Bitcoin exposure and $100 of exposure to the other assets per $100 in fund assets, with $186 of futures exposure used to carry the remaining-index position. The example excludes Bitcoin Cash, fees, financing and differences between the futures contracts; ARK had not disclosed its intended exposure target. Its filing warned that operations would be “characterized by a high degree of leverage.” In this setup, the short would offset the Bitcoin embedded in the long position rather than express a directional view on Bitcoin.
The futures positions would have needed ongoing adjustment as the index and fund value changed. ARK said it would “periodically adjust” them, and quarterly index rebalances would also change the Bitcoin exposure to be offset. Contracts would need to be rolled as they expired; when later-dated futures cost more than expiring contracts, rolling the long position costs money while the short can benefit from the price gap. Bitcoin Cash added a potential tracking mismatch because CME Bitcoin futures would not necessarily move in line with it.
A Bitcoin rally could create mark-to-market losses on the short and require additional margin from Treasury holdings, even as the long position gained. ARK also described the central index futures as “new instruments without a significant trading history.”
The withdrawal does not establish why ARK abandoned the funds: the two products shared the ICE futures contract and commodity-pool structure, but ARK did not connect either feature to its decision. The article notes that the SEC had approved generic listing standards for certain spot-commodity products, including digital assets, four months before the January filings; the filings and withdrawal letters did not explain ARK’s choice of futures. The withdrawal also says nothing about investor demand, since no shares were sold and there were no fund flows, redemptions or trading volumes. ARK’s existing spot Bitcoin ETF, ARKB, offered with 21Shares, has traded since January 2024 and was unaffected. The sizing example is hypothetical, not a disclosure of ARK’s allocations or actual returns.




